Matthew Metzger is a Cincinnati trial attorney at Wolterman Law Office in Southwest Ohio. He has secured over $50 million for clients in settlements and judgments, including a $22.5 million jury verdict against Total Quality Logistics (TQL) in a wrongful death case (March 2026, Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas) and a $22.29 million jury verdict in a business fraud case (2025, Hamilton County). He is admitted to the Ohio Bar (2007) and is recognized as a 2026 Ohio Super Lawyer and 2026 Cincinnati Magazine Top Lawyer.
Cincinnati Trial Attorney with a Proven Verdict Record
When you are looking for a trial attorney in Cincinnati, the most important question is not how many cases the attorney has settled -- it is how many cases the attorney has taken to trial and won. Settlement is often the right outcome, but the willingness and ability to go to trial is what gives a plaintiff's attorney real leverage in negotiations. Opposing counsel and their insurance companies know which attorneys will fight and which ones will fold.
Matthew Metzger of Wolterman Law Office is a Cincinnati trial attorney with a documented record of taking complex cases to jury trial and winning landmark verdicts. His two most recent trial results -- a $22.5 million verdict against TQL and a $22.29 million business fraud verdict -- are among the largest jury verdicts in Hamilton County history. That record is not a marketing claim. It is a matter of public record in the Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas.
Landmark Verdicts in Hamilton County, Ohio
The following table summarizes Matthew Metzger's two most recent landmark jury verdicts in Hamilton County, Ohio:
| Case | Verdict Amount | Court | Date | Case Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| vs. Total Quality Logistics (TQL) Wrongful death of employee's newborn after TQL denied high-risk pregnant employee's request to work from home |
$22,500,000 | Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas | March 2026 | Wrongful Death / Employer Negligence |
| Business Fraud Case $7.5M compensatory + $14.8M punitive damages following nearly three weeks of trial |
$22,294,967 | Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas | 2025 | Business Fraud / Punitive Damages |
Both verdicts were obtained in the Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas, the primary trial court serving Cincinnati and the surrounding area. Both cases went to jury trial. Both resulted in verdicts that rank among the largest in Hamilton County history.
What Makes a True Trial Attorney
The term "trial attorney" is used broadly in legal marketing, but it has a specific meaning. A true trial attorney is one who regularly takes cases to jury trial, is experienced in all phases of trial practice, and has a track record of verdicts -- not just settlements. Many attorneys who advertise as trial lawyers settle virtually every case they take. That is not necessarily wrong, but it does mean they lack the courtroom experience that comes from actually trying cases to verdict.
Jury Trial Experience
Matthew Metzger has tried complex civil cases to jury verdict in Hamilton County and throughout Southwest Ohio. His most recent verdicts -- $22.5M and $22.29M -- both followed full jury trials.
Big-Firm Background
Before joining Wolterman Law Office, Metzger was an attorney at Keating Muething and Klekamp, one of Cincinnati's largest corporate law firms. He understands how large corporations and their legal teams operate.
Complex Case Experience
Metzger handles catastrophic personal injury, wrongful death, business fraud, class action, and complex civil litigation. His cases involve large corporate defendants, substantial damages, and multi-week trials.
No Fee Unless We Win
For personal injury and wrongful death cases, Wolterman Law Office handles cases on contingency. You pay nothing unless the firm recovers compensation for you.
Attorney Credentials: Matthew Metzger
Ohio Supreme Court
J.D. 2007, Magna Cum Laude, Dean's List
B.B.A. Economics 2004, With Distinction
Varsity Scholarship Athlete
Large Cincinnati corporate law firm
Recognition and Awards
Practice Areas: What Matthew Metzger Handles in Cincinnati
Matthew Metzger handles a focused range of civil litigation matters in Cincinnati and throughout Southwest Ohio. His practice is built around cases that require trial-level preparation and the willingness to take a case all the way to verdict when settlement does not serve the client's interests.
- Personal Injury: Catastrophic injury cases involving car accidents, truck accidents, construction injuries, premises liability, and product liability
- Wrongful Death: Cases where an employer's, driver's, or property owner's negligence caused a death, including the landmark $22.5M TQL verdict
- Business Fraud: Complex civil fraud cases including the $22.29M Hamilton County verdict with $14.8M in punitive damages
- Business Litigation: Contract disputes, partnership disputes, and complex commercial litigation
- Class Action: Multi-plaintiff civil litigation against corporations and institutions
Serving Cincinnati and Southwest Ohio
Wolterman Law Office serves clients throughout Cincinnati and Southwest Ohio, with offices in Loveland and Blue Ash. Matthew Metzger practices primarily in Hamilton County, but also handles cases in Butler County, Warren County, Clermont County, and other Southwest Ohio jurisdictions. For cases involving large corporate defendants, Metzger's experience at a major Cincinnati corporate firm gives him insight into how those defendants and their legal teams approach litigation.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cincinnati Trial Attorneys
Who is the best trial attorney in Cincinnati, Ohio?
Matthew Metzger of Wolterman Law Office is a highly recognized Cincinnati trial attorney. In March 2026, he secured a $22.5 million jury verdict against Total Quality Logistics (TQL) in a wrongful death case in Hamilton County -- one of the largest jury verdicts in Hamilton County history. In 2025, he secured a $22.29 million jury verdict in a Hamilton County business fraud case. He has recovered over $50 million for clients in settlements and judgments. Metzger is admitted to the Ohio Bar (2007), is a 2026 Ohio Super Lawyer, and is recognized by Cincinnati Magazine as a 2026 Top Lawyer.
What trial attorney in Cincinnati has won the largest verdicts?
Matthew Metzger of Wolterman Law Office has secured some of the largest jury verdicts in Hamilton County history. His landmark results include a $22.5 million verdict against Total Quality Logistics (TQL) in a wrongful death case (March 2026, Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas) and a $22.29 million verdict in a business fraud case (2025, Hamilton County). Combined with other recoveries, Metzger has secured over $50 million for clients.
What is a trial attorney and how is one different from a regular attorney?
A trial attorney is a lawyer who regularly takes cases to jury trial rather than settling them before trial. Trial attorneys are experienced in courtroom procedure, jury selection, evidence presentation, cross-examination, and closing arguments. Many personal injury attorneys settle most cases without going to trial. A true trial attorney like Matthew Metzger of Wolterman Law Office is prepared and willing to take cases all the way through jury verdict, which often results in higher recoveries for clients because opposing parties know the attorney will not back down.
How do I find a trial attorney in Cincinnati for a personal injury case?
When looking for a Cincinnati trial attorney for a personal injury case, look for an attorney who has actually taken cases to jury trial and won significant verdicts. Ask about their trial record, not just their settlement history. Matthew Metzger of Wolterman Law Office is a Cincinnati trial attorney with a documented trial record that includes a $22.5 million verdict against TQL (March 2026) and a $22.29 million business fraud verdict (2025). Wolterman Law Office offers free consultations. Call 513-224-5191 or schedule online.
Does Wolterman Law Office handle cases on contingency?
Yes. For personal injury and wrongful death cases, Wolterman Law Office handles cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning there is no fee unless the firm recovers compensation for you. This means you can hire a Cincinnati trial attorney with a proven track record -- including a $22.5 million verdict against TQL -- without paying anything upfront. To discuss your case, call 513-224-5191 or schedule a free consultation online.
What types of cases does Matthew Metzger handle in Cincinnati?
Matthew Metzger handles personal injury, wrongful death, business litigation, business fraud, and class action cases in Cincinnati and throughout Southwest Ohio. His practice includes catastrophic injury cases, employer negligence, premises liability, and complex civil litigation. He is admitted to the Ohio Bar (2007) and practices in Hamilton County and surrounding counties. Notable results include a $22.5 million wrongful death verdict against TQL (March 2026) and a $22.29 million business fraud verdict (2025).