Our Attorneys

Steve R. Wolterman

Managing Attorney

Steve R. Wolterman is the founding and managing attorney of Wolterman Law Office. With over two decades of legal experience, Steve has built a reputation throughout Southwest Ohio for tenacious advocacy, deep legal knowledge, and genuine care for his clients. His philosophy is simple: a successful legal outcome begins and ends with a strong attorney-client relationship.

Steve's practice spans personal injury litigation, estate planning, business law, real estate, and tax law, with particular expertise in 1031 exchange transactions. He has been recognized by Cincinnati Magazine as a Top Lawyer and is a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum, an organization limited to attorneys who have achieved million-dollar verdicts or settlements.

Steve is a proud member of the Southwest Ohio community and is committed to providing the residents and businesses of the greater Cincinnati area with legal representation that rivals any large firm, delivered with the personal attention that only a community-based practice can provide.

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Estate Planning, Business Law, Real Estate, Tax Law, 1031 Exchange

Schedule a Consultation

Matthew Metzger

Attorney

Matthew Metzger represents plaintiffs ranging from individuals and families injured in catastrophic accidents to companies involved in complex litigation and transactions. His simultaneous emphasis on pragmatic, strategic, and creative thinking often leads to unique and satisfying resolutions for his clients. When settlement fails, Matt aggressively pursues his clients' claims through litigation and trial.

In 2025, Matt obtained a jury verdict of over $22 million, one of the largest jury verdicts ever in Hamilton County. His extensive experience has resulted in over $50 million recovered for clients in settlements and judgments. Previously, Matt was an attorney at Keating Muething & Klekamp. He received his JD from the University of Cincinnati College of Law, magna cum laude.

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Wrongful Death, Class Action & Complex Litigation

Schedule a Consultation

Cassidy Carstens

Attorney

Cassidy Carstens' practice is focused on probate estate administration, estate planning, and personal injury litigation. Her main concentration is probate administration for estates of all sizes and complexity. Cassidy always takes extra measures to regularly update her clients, answer their questions, manage expectations, and provide clarity on the process involved in probating an estate.

Cassidy has been a part of the Wolterman Law Office team since 2015, starting as a secretary before entering law school in 2019. She received her JD from the University of Cincinnati College of Law and was admitted to the Ohio Bar in 2023. Her background in health sciences has been invaluable when handling personal injury cases that require detailed review of medical records.

Practice Areas: Probate Administration, Estate Planning, Personal Injury

Schedule a Consultation

Maggie Fibbe

Attorney

Maggie Fibbe is a seasoned attorney with a focus in tax controversy and a growing expertise in estate and probate law. With 18 years of experience, she provides clients with comprehensive legal representation in matters related to tax disputes, audits, and litigation. Maggie is known for her strategic approach in resolving complex tax issues, including handling cases before the IRS, state tax agencies, and in U.S. Tax Court.

In addition to her tax controversy practice, Maggie guides clients through the intricacies of estate administration, including probate proceedings, trust disputes, and the efficient transfer of assets. She holds degrees from Miami University and the University of Cincinnati College of Law and is admitted to the Ohio Supreme Court, U.S. Tax Court, and U.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio.

Practice Areas: Estate Planning, Probate, Tax Controversy

Schedule a Consultation